| Because of the ways stockbrokers
are paid, some may be thinking more about how much money they can make
off of your investments than in giving you sound advice. The odds are that
you have been dealing with a well-trained, ethical stock broker. However,
you need to understand how brokers get paid so you can be sure you are
getting value for what you are paying.
What You Should Know
Recognize that a stockbroker is
a salesperson.
Most investors pay for broker
services through a commission on each investment transaction. A good stockbroker
will propose investments that are tailored to your goals and financial
situation. However, it is possible that the amount of money the broker
will earn from your investments can influence his or her recommendation.
Keep in mind that brokers' earnings
generally come from how often and how many shares their clients buy and
sell, not from the success of the particular investment. In other words,
brokers can make money even if you don't. Although your stockbroker has
a long-term incentive for you to succeed - to keep your account and gain
your referrals - your broker also has a short-term incentive to earn commissions.
Consider any recommendation to buy or sell stock just as you would any
other solicitation. Don't confuse a sales pitch with impartial advice.
Noted personal finance columnist
Jane Bryant Quinn recommends that you ask your broker these questions every
time he or she recommends an investment:
Why are you suggesting this?
Does it meet my investment goals?
What are the commissions and other
transaction costs?
Make it your business to learn
about commissions.
Commissions come in every shape
and size. Depending on the investment product, you will find up-front commissions,
commissions spread out for as long as you hold the product, or those paid
when you sell the product. Commissions paid at the time you invest are
called front-end or up-front fees, or "loads." Commissions paid when you
take your money out of the investment are called back-end fees or "deferred
loads." On some investments, such as municipal bonds, brokers don't get
sales commissions. Instead, they are paid from the "mark up" - the difference
between the price the brokerage firm pays to buy the investment and the
price it charges you.
Be aware that commissions can
reduce the value of your investment. For example, if you put $10,000 into
a mutual fund and your broker earns an up-front 5 percent commission on
the transaction, $500 would go to the broker and $9,500 would be invested.
Always know what you are paying
your broker.
You have the right to full disclosure
of all costs of each investment. Ask your broker about commission rates,
annual fees, transaction costs, and any other expenses. No fee should show
up on any confirmation slip or account statement that you haven't been
told about in advance. Make sure you have no surprises by asking ahead
of time about commissions and comparing costs with other brokers.
The bottom line:
You have the right to full disclosure
of all investment costs from your broker.
Be aware of sales contests, bonuses,
and other payment practices.
Brokers may encourage you to buy
certain investment products that bring them extra income through higher
commissions, bonuses, or even points toward a vacation. Some brokerage
firms give their brokers incentives to sell "house brand" investment products
created or managed by the firm. More risky or complex investment products
could earn a broker a higher commission, resulting in your increased risk
and the broker's gain.
When a broker recommends an investment
because of special incentives, you run the risk that the broker places
interest in earning points for a vacation ahead of selecting the best investment
for you. It's appropriate to ask brokers if they are receiving any special
compensation for their recommendations.
Read and understand your confirmation
slips.
A confirmation statement is exactly
what it sounds like-a notice confirming your buy or sell order. It should
show the product, price, and broker's commission.
Even if the confirmation states
"zero" for commission, this does not necessarily mean the broker has not
been paid. For example, you won't see the broker's compensation when you
buy new issue stocks and bonds because the commission is paid by the issuing
company. Stock and bonds sold out of the brokerage firm's inventory also
may not show a commission. However, a broker makes money on every one of
your transactions. In fact, your broker may earn more on these "zero-commission"
sales than by selling other investments.
Keep track of your confirmation
slips. If the commission isn't shown, ask what the broker is getting paid
and make note of it on your confirmation slip. These slips will come in
handy to tally up what you pay each year in fees and commissions.
Read and understand your monthly
account statements.
Each month your brokerage firm
sends you an account statement. Don't throw it away or toss it in a drawer.
Make sure you review it each month. Be smart about what the statement tells
you and how to use it to your advantage.
Set up a system to track two important
items: how you're doing and what it's costing. Keep a running list of the
commissions and fees you pay for your investments. If you see transactions
you didn't authorize, or if your broker appears to be trading excessively,
contact your broker's supervisor immediately. Don't wait to see how the
investments perform, as waiting may be viewed as giving your approval to
the unauthorized trades.
Consider alternative compensation
arrangements.
Some brokerage firms offer accounts
with no commissions. Instead, you pay an annual fee, usually based on the
amount you have invested. In return you get a certain number of trades
each year. Such a fee arrangement presumably removes any broker incentive
to sell high-commission products or to increase trading frequency to earn
higher commissions. Under a fee arrangement, the broker's income rises
only if your assets do. Talk to your broker about flat-fee arrangements
or try to negotiate a lower commission-per-transaction rate.
Check out a broker's record.
Before working with any broker,
take a look at his or her training and disciplinary records. The National
Association of Securities Dealers (NASD) and your state securities agency
can provide you with extensive information on any broker you are considering
working with. This could help you spot a broker you don't want to trust
with your money. Too many people have lost their life savings because they
were too polite, or too trusting, to check out a broker's credentials.
Any broker should be properly
registered with the National Association of Securities Dealers and your
state's securities agency.
For More Information
National Association of Securities
Dealers
The National Association of Securities
Dealers (NASD) has a Public Disclosure Line for information on brokers.
Call 1-800-289-9999. On NASD's Web site, you can learn about its Regulation
Complaint Program and can file a complaint online against a stockbroker.
North American Securities Administrators
Association (NASAA)
The NASAA can give you the telephone
number of your state securities agency. Go to their Web site on Find Regulators.
URL: www.nasaa.org/
Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
The FTC has more information
on investment risks and tips for informed investing.
URL: www.ftc.gov/bcp/conline/pubs/invest/invrisks.htm
Securities and Exchange Commission
(SEC)
The SEC can help you check out
brokers and advisors.
URL: www.sec.gov/consumer/jchkout.htm |